I'm almost done with the first (pretty raw) draft of BEAUTIFUL GHOSTS. Of course, now that I've almost finished it in 3rd-person, past tense, I am thinking of switching to 1st-person, present tense during revisions. Heh. I always do this...
Just wondering if anyone has thoughts on 1st-person, present tense POV? And especially any recommendations in the YA field - any subgenre of YA is fine. Doesn't have to be paranormal.
Cheers!
Just wondering if anyone has thoughts on 1st-person, present tense POV? And especially any recommendations in the YA field - any subgenre of YA is fine. Doesn't have to be paranormal.
Cheers!
- Mood:
thoughtful


Comments
I can't think of any examples in YA, but Grimspace is my favorite book I've read in...oh, I don't know. A while. And I think the 1st person present really works for it.
-Bree
:D
What POV is your book written in?
As for examples, I can't think of one off the top of my head, but I know I've read one not that long ago...
I haven't read The Adoration of Jenna Fox yet. And you *totally* make sense - I really need to read that book. Thanks.
And of COURSE! *facepalm* Yes, yours was beautiful in 1st-person present - that slightly surreal quality was pefect for FHT.
Excellent 1st/present YA books are:
Need by Carrie Jones - great contemporary setting [and pixies! Yay!]
Hunger Games - Suzanne Collins
Forest of Hands and Teeth - Carrie Ryan
Yes, Wicked Game is awesome. I still have to read the sequel... *Sigh* I can't believe I haven't read Need yet. Wow, I am very bad because I <3 Carrie and should read it. I just struggle to by hardbacks these days.
And of course, both The Hunger Games and FHT were 1st-person, present. I forgot about them (I don't know how that's possible).
Thanks!!
I found it was easier to connect in 1st person, and quite frankly, I had far fewer blocks because I could always sit and "talk" to my mc, hear her voice, and let her help me. I think it *does* depend on the project. The editor I'm revising my 1st book for said she liked that project third person, past tense. But it was a very different book from my 2nd.
Yes, the project itself really is the deciding factor. And thanks for your comment - that part about 'talking' to the mc is a good way of thinking of it. :)
Thanks!
*goes off to experiment*
But when it doesn't work - which is far more often than not (i.e. I really, intensely disliked GRIMSPACE, and part of that stemmed from the unbelievable voice) - it's terrible. I don't think there's any narrative POV that bugs more readers than the poorly done 1st-person present tense. *shudders*
~ Thea
You're right that it's the trickiest POV to pull off. *sigh* I like GRIMSPACE, though it didn't have me running out to buy the sequel. You know, the more I think about it - and these comments are helping me a LOT - I think I might try it in 1st-person, past. The thing is, my usual choice of 3rd-person, past just isn't working. Well, I don't think it is. I've pretty much finished this whole draft and now it feels a little... limp. heh.
Thanks for commenting though, luv!
But saying that, I'm sure I've read books with it and it's been done so well I haven't noticed. But once I do notice...
I don't have any YA recommendations since I've been reading mostly adult stuff lately, but Jeri Smith-Ready and Ann Aguirre are to blame for my choice of POV/tense. I never considered writing present tense until their books. I tried to write the WIP past and it won't have it.
I'm surprised your book will let you change. You have so much more control over your creation than I do, LOL.
I read Marjorie Liu's Hunter Kiss novella and loved it - that's in 1st/present, but now the first book in the actual series - The Iron Hunt - has switched to 1st/past. *sniff* I was quite sad about that, although the book is still good. Jeanne Stein writes adult UF in 1st/present. She's fab!
LOL! I don't know about the control thing... And now that I'm actually trying it out and looking into it, I think I might have to shift to 1st-person PAST if it's going to work. Hmm... Also, we should meet up soon!
Anyway, YA I can think of in that tense are:
Forest of Hands and Teeth
Dull Boy
Wake
Gemma Doyle Trilogy
The Hunger Games
Thanks for the recs.
Thanks!
Now that most of the books I read are 1st person, I do find myself hesitating to pick up a 3rd person book. Weird of me, I know.
Something else that I like Devon Monk did in her first book, Magic to the Bone. The book was mainly 1st person, past tense, but there were passages that were in the 3rd person. It created a mystery, because you weren't sure who's pov it was. Very mysterious. I liked it, worked well for the story.
It has to be what feels comfortable to you though, as you stated earlier.
I have no problem with first person, but it does present challenges to the writer. Your protag has to be on stage pretty much all the time. Anything simply told to him or her gets diluted. In my opinion, books with multiple narrators really, really need to be third person.